Laughable Graphs
This week, the state of Georgia shared the following graph as evidence for why it reopened the state for “normal business operations”.
What do you notice? What do you wonder? What’s the story this graph is supposed to tell?
What you might notice is that the dates along the x-axis come in no particular order. You may wonder if the story being this graph is to lead viewers to believing the state has had a significant decrease in the number of COVID-19 cases over time. The governor has since issued an apology addressing the misinformation the graph represents. Can you believe it? A mathematical misrepresentation generated an apology! This is big news.
When I first viewed this graph on Twitter, I could not help but laugh at the captions. Not a maniacal laugh. Not a “haha that’s so funny” graph. No…this kind:
The kind that recognizes that these graphs are used to make real decisions that impact real people.
Bob Lochel (@bobloch) shared the balanced sentiment of the joy of having new content to talk through with students and the sunken pit of the stomach feeling that the new content even exists. Same, Bob. Same.
So I culled together several laughable graphs (jokes on you, it’s not that funny) that have been used in real situations. For each one, I suggest asking yourself the same three questions as before:
What do you notice? What do you wonder? What’s the story this graph is supposed to tell?
I’d also invite you to ask yourself one more question: What’s the real story?
With all the (mis)information being passed around right now, it is important to find sources for data that describe the real story, what is actually happening, rather than the fictional world we wish we had.
Oh. Wait. That last one is just the story of my own life right now, and I’m sure the same for some of you as well. Solidarity, friends.
Remotely Yours,
Lauren Baucom
@LBMathemagician
|